Quote: "Mira's daughter, Edwidge?" she said. Her lower lip was dropping, slightly slurring her speech. Tante Denise said this quote on page 142.
Significance: When I read the whole page that this quote was on, I felt really bad for Uncle Joseph and Tante Denise. They live in a very bad part of town and it is possible that they could get killed any day, and I think that stress of being so scared has aged Edwidge's aunt and uncle so much that they are always tried and just out of it. I also felt really bad because at first Edwidge didn't really think that her aunt was the same person, the beautiful aunt that she had left in Haiti had turned into a thin small women.
Character Judgment: I think that Tante Denise had changed so much in the years that Edwidge has been away. I think that because of everything that has happened to Tante Denise (Marie dying, the violence in Bel Air) she has just wilted away to this small person that just stays in her home all day. I hope that because Edwidge has come to visit Tante Denise, Edwidge will somehow get Tante Denise and Uncle Joseph to leave Bel Air and move to a safer place in Haiti.
Question: Why do you think that Uncle Joseph won't move out of Bel Air?
Quote 2: "I only remember wishing as we soared into the clouds that my uncle had cried a torrent of tears, had thrown himself on the ground and made a scene, all the while forbidding us to go. He should have blurted out, in his old voice, the sudden revelation that I was really his daughter and that he could live without me." Edwidge said this one page 109
Significance: I think that this shows how much her uncle has been a father figure to Edwidge, and how much she wished that she was able to stay with her Uncle Joseph in Haiti. I also think that this shows how much her father not being there for her has affected her. It has affected her in the way that she doesn't really want to go to America and spend the rest of her life in a new place with new people that she doesn't really know.
Character Judgment: I think that Edwidge had a right to not want to live with her mom and dad because they weren't there for her when she was young and she had learned to love and live with her uncle and aunt without them. So I was a little sad to read that she didn't want to go to America, but it was also happy to see that her uncle had affected her life so much and how much she loves hims and wants to be with him.
Question: Do you think that Edwidge's little brother, Bob, felt the same way that she did?
3 comments:
Quote 1: I think that they don't want to leave that part of town because all of the people that they know live there and its their home. It's the only place that they know and they help other people in that community.
Question 1: I think that he and his wife really love it their even though it is the slums, it wasn't when they moved there. they still know the good parts of it.
Quote 2: Yes I agree I think that she really is a daughter to him and they really love each other a lot but she has to go.
Question 2: I think that he did more then her because he barley knew his parents before they left to America so his uncle is like a dad to him.
Quote 1: I definitely feel that Tante Denise is upset that her “children” are now only 3 feet apart and yet so far away.
Response 1: I agree Rachel, Uncle Joseph and Aunt Tante Denise do live in the worst part in town, but it is the best that they an afford. Also, Joseph and Denise are different from the last they saw of them.
Question 1: Well they can only afford the house that they live in, they can't move because they will be living on the streets.
Quote 2: Ha, that shows that Joseph and Edwidge can't live without each other, they are the real father-daughter family.
Response 2: Well Edwidge is going to see her family in the states, but she will miss her other family in Haiti.
Question 2: Well he will miss his aunt and uncle, but he always wanted to go to the states to be with his “real” family.
Quote one: I agree how you said "smaller person." She isn't treated and looked at as important as she should be treated. I also think that there is a lot of stress living in a unsafe environment where you feel unsecure.
Question one: I think even though it's not safe they love the people they are around and they know the good side of the town and know how to be safe.
Quote two: Yeah, I think it must be very hard for them to separate and I felt the same way you did as far as emotions went.
Question two:I think he did less because he didn't know them quite as well he can't have as much emotion, or even more because he wants to see them even more.
Post a Comment